• Recommended Posts

  • Browse By Category

  • Browse By Timeline

Who is more corrupt? Middle class Indians or politicians?


On one my recent flights within USA, I had privilege of sitting next to a gentleman from India.  I don’t know how many NRIs it takes to change a lightbulb, but I know for sure how many minutes NRIs need to start talking about corrupt politicians  in India. One is enough. Two are ample.

So we started.

Certainly mostly people agree that Indian politicians are no shining examples of honesty. But this gentleman was really extreme. In less than ten minutes he must have uttered the word corruption atleast 50 times. In addition used some words to describe the politicians that I would not dare utter in front of my family members. By the end of three hour flight, I was utterly feeling like I bathed in poison spurting out of his mouth. The last straw on the camel’s back was when he said that British should take back India because Indians don’t deserve democracy. At that point I told him I very strongly disagree with him and I would put my thoughts on my blog and will send him the link.

So here is a reality check.

  • We, middle class Indians, learn on taxpayer’s money, but if we get a chance, we immigrate to Europe or USA.
  • While hundreds of Army officer posts remain vacant, we complain about unemployment.
  • We pirate music.
  • We pirate movies.
  • We pirate software, (“Who buys Microsoft windows anyway!’)
  • We don’t vote, almost half of us.
  • We don’t prosecute. We avoid courts like plague.
  • We don’t testify in courts if it is even slightly risky.
  • When “Missing persons” pictures are being shown on TV, we switch channels.
  • We are not that willing to donate money. We use corruption in NGOs as an excuse to not donate.
  • Bone marrow registry in USA is seriously lacking Asian Indian donors.
  • Middle class , in their zeal of finding risk-free-prosperity, is flocking behind Amway and Quikster. For some reason those people have fooled us in believing that we can make a big profit without taking major risk.

The above list shows that morally Indian middle class is as corrupt as politicians. No?

Middle class Indians are  disgruntled about state of Indian politics and democracy. But here is the irony. Most of the macro indicators of a country’s progress, like GDP growth, average life expectancy, literacy, survival rate in childbirth, are consistently showing upward trend for last several decades. India has lost one but won three wars and now boasts fourth strongest army in the world. ISRO is scaling new heights in space exploration every year. Lot of this progress has happened due to policy Initiatives that came from politicians we all blame for corruption. And the biggest beneficiary of these upward trends has been, guess who, middle class in India.

The truth is when something good happens, we , middle class Indians tend to either attribute it to chance or tend to take credit ourselves. We are in denial that the root of many of these developments can be traced back to something gone right in politics. Here are a few examples.

  • In 1960s, the corrupt Indian politicians combined several old departments and created ISRO , which is one of the worlds premier space research organizations today.
  • In 1960s, the corrupt Indian politicians launched green revolution in 1960s that made India self reliant for food.
  • In 1990s, the corrupt  Indian politicians liberalized economy. This made computers cheap and opened up new world for educated Indians-the world of information technology.
  • In 1990s, the corrupt Indian politicians launched pulse polio initiative.  80 million children were vaccinated for Polio, thus drastically reducing Polio cases in India. All the would-be Polio victim children who would have been liabilities on society, are now today assets of society.
  • In 1980s, the corrupt Indian politicians launched the telecommunication reforms  which led to creation of DOT, or Department of Telecommunication. This separated telecommunications from postal services. (They were combined by British, because in their time telecommunication was limited to telegraph, which came under postal services.) This change pretty much unshackled telecommunication sector in India.The deregulation and liberalization continued which resulted in opening up Television transmission and allowed creation of many channels. It further repelled an 1899 law that kept airwaves in strict control of government, thus allowing private sector radio channels.
  • In 1970s, corrupt Indian politicians  launched rural education initiative that resulted in almost doubling the women’s literacy rates. Another initiative for family planning helped slowing down the rate of population growth. (Yes, not as successful as we want it to be, but there was a big initiative and it made difference.)
  • In 1970s, initiatives were launched to spread use of gober gas, thus reducing rate of deforestation.
  • In 200s, Indian politicians repelled the Indian forest act passed by British in 1027., all the forests belonged to central government, giving British right to exploit those forests for war efforts. This changed and gave the aboriginals the rights of the forest. Middle class Indians argued that this could lead to rapid deforestation because the aboriginals would be cheated by builders and land mafia. In fact this has slowed deforestation because the jungle dwellers feel far more attached to their forest than we think.
  • In 2000s, Indian politicians passed right to information act. According to this act, Indian citizen could request information on most of the government matters including tender process and government had binding responsibility to respond in timely manner or the matter could be escalated.  This was a great tool. Many active citizens and social workers used this to expose corruption.
  • In 2000s, rural employment guarantee act was launched that created more job opportunities for rural youth.

You can find corruption cases in each of the policy initiatives listed above. But what you are reading only about bad apples. No one prints about things that have gone right. No one prints about the bridges that did not collapse. Over the big picture, large time scale, these policy initiatives by corrupt and dirty Indian politicians have made far more difference than whining middle classes have made.

The If we don’t like something, we complain. But we never form a group and try to change it. Our excuse is the whole system is corrupt. Well, we don’t have to change the whole system. Just a small positive change can be a beginning.

The truth is we are naive when it comes to social change. We, somewhere inside, still believe in a Bollywood hero to come and take care of it all for us, without we risking anything. Like the Amway business above, we dream of risk free revolution. Democracy has given us tools like (and ability to create tools like) Right to Information act. But if we don’t use these tools, nothing is going to change by itself. Politics might be bad, but it is better than all other options. And Ram-rajya is only fiction, and things like benevolent dictator, do not last long.

Moral of the story – Large scale social change can only happen through a system improvement. System improvement takes time, takes patience, takes effort, takes honest and sincere introspection, takes positive activism. Which one of these have we provided? Just wanting is not enough. Are we motivated enough to spill blood, sweat and tears it takes to get there?

If corrupt politicians is our only ticket to get there, then may be we should stop talking about their corruption and see if there is anything we can do to help them in making this social change happen. Just a thought.

6 Responses

  1. This was a brave post that I truly enjoyed reading!

  2. Well most of “we” middle class Indians don’t do the things that you say..

    Only a few migrate after learning on tax payers money and contribute back through remmitance (I am still in India, working) without there being too much wrong in that. The tax payers are paying to enable the Indian youth so that they have a livelihood.. There is not specific clause for contribution to Indian economy (even though that happens with 99% of us)

    Just because you don’t have a job doesn’t mean you take up any job that is vacant – Indian army is not waiting with arms wide open for “All India rejects” and that is not the ideal job for someone who does not have the passion for it!

    Rest of it (except piracy) is not even immoral, let alone illegal!! Don’t think that comparison is coming out right… Politicians’ corruption is counterproductive to the very job that they are entrusted withWhat you are comparing to is nothing to do with “We” Middle class Indian’s jobs, just their personal choices..

  3. I think it’s the duty of a person to not only vote but to advocate their position upon request so that a vote could happen at anytime with predictable results because the opinion of every citizen is well known. Any reason for having to hide a political opinion, is a shame for the country and illuminates a problem. Then voting is not only a civil action but a cue to rally the masses if we find the government was corrupt and failed to listen.

  4. […] my previous post, I have given list of institutional reforms in India brought in by our much criticized Indian […]

  5. We know of 1 person who was the architect of economic reforms in 1991 and he is still the person who is behind the reforms in many sector today. If there are 10 people who make policy decisions that benefit the country there are 100 politicians who are so corrupt that every good move made by the government seems insignificant. An RTI act can’t justify the CWG and 2G scams, moreover RTI when used by RTI activists they are murdered by policticians.

    As far as the middle class is concerned , I won’t give them a clean chit. every work in a government office requires bribes, but I don’t agree with the justifications given in the main post to prove them corrupt. NRIs remit a huge amount of money back to the country. Gujrat is a prime example of this.Also taxpayer’s money is used by the government in educational institutions to give its citizens better way of living. They are as it is going to return the money through taxes .

    But we value ourselves and our ability to bring change in ourselves and the society to live a better life, and we are definitely not like the NRI who thought that the colonial rulers would do all good thinks without massive exploitation.

    • We Indians are worst human race. we Indians are worst Hippocratic people on the earth. We Indians are most insensitive, most in compassionate humans. I will give just one example. I can put picture of martin luther king, karl marx in my drawing room but i can not put picture of Ambedkar and if i put Ambedkar`s picture will i be able wed in arrange marriage style?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: