• Recommended Posts

  • Browse By Category

  • Browse By Timeline

It’s The Policy, Stupid !!


“It’s the economy stupid!” was the catchphrase in Bill Clinton’s campaign for presidency. Later on this phrase (and it’s many variations) became a part of American political culture. And the reason I am throwing a decade old catchphrase at you? Read on.

Before a few days I had a chance to visit a function. Outside the hall some people were sitting with forms and pamphlets. They were volunteers of an non profit organization working to raise awareness about eye donation. While I admired their dedication to the cause and the compassion they felt towards who don’t have eyes, I could not help but think “Is this the best way to tackle this issue?”

These people are here because not enough people donate their eyes. Why don’t people donate their eyes? Because people are lazy. People don’t want to go out of their way unless they have to. You really can’t blame them, as everybody is fighting this hard battle called life.

But there are blind people who need eyes today. And lots of dead bodies are being burned with eyes that could have been used to give eyesight to blind people.

How about use people’s laziness to make sure they donate eyes?

When India became independent, we copied our policies and regulations mostly from Britain. Britain has this thing called “Opt In” policy, where if you wish to donate your organs, you need to sign papers saying you wish to do so.

While just a few hundred Kilometers away from Britain, there is Spain. Spain has what they called “Opt out” policy. So by default you are considered organ donor and your organs are harvested at your death. But if you do not want to donate organs, you have to sign papers saying that explicitly.

Result? Spain has a lot higher rate of organ donation.

If people spent their time lobbying to change regulation instead of raising awareness, they would solve the organ donation problem permanently. Thousands of people waiting for organs would have a chance of life. If these people walk out of hospitals, hospitals and doctors will be free to cater to the people with other life threatening ailments. All these healthy people will be transformed from liabilities to assets, which will be a tremendous social and economical boost.

We have our democracy. But role of our citizens is limited to casting a vote once in five years. That needs to be changed. The citizens need to consistently engage pro-actively in policy discussions and lobbying efforts to change policies that are unfavorable to the society. This will generate a lot stronger long term impact compared to the volunteer non profit work.

Don’t get me wrong. I am not talking bad about volunteers. Heck, I have shown far less commitment to welfare of society then they show.

But the volunteers can only make so much of a difference. If the long term, nationwide impact is desired, then there is no substitute to policy change.

The real event that unrestrained India from shackles of doomed socialist economy to a vibrant powerhouse of Asia was precisely this, a policy change. A decision to dismantle the license raj, brilliantly masterminded by our then financial minister, ManMohan Singh, is at the root of all this miracle.

There is another example of how policy change can literally transform the related industry. In India, FM radio frequencies were licensed solely to Government of India according to a regulation passed in 1897 that grouped the wireless radio waves in the same category as telegraph, filed under “communication using electric signals”. Thus there were only a handful FM radio stations in operation. But when these licenses were opened for businesses just a decade ago, the number of FM stations grew exponentially, generating a lot more jobs, advertising revenue, and supporting business.

Democracy is not something we suffer silently. Democracy is a great tool to make our lives better. It’s time to hammer the nail where it will make the biggest difference. It’s time to unlock the secret to the happy and prosperous nation.

The secret? It’s “the policy”, stupid !!

5 Responses

  1. […] https://kedarsoman.wordpress.com/2008/07/18/its-the-policy-stupid/ When India became independent, we copied our policies and regulations mostly from Britain. Britain has this thing called “Opt In” policy, where if you wish to donate your organs, you need to sign papers saying you wish to do so. […]

  2. i’ve quoted your article in my blog. I hope its not a problem.

  3. Whilst I agree an opt in system has come merits it is not the only answer and I would be careful dismissing raising awareness.

    There are a few problems with an Opt out system, first many officials woryr it would be too contraversial so some countries are unlikely to ever change their policy, Second if the system were to change there would be a sudden increase in the number of organs being donated, while this is great there needs to be an extremely strong system in place first to handle such a change and ensure organs are not wasted.

    Finally, many transplants do not take place because the family of the donor over rule and this is a problem an opt in cannot solve because whatever the law, doctors tend to listen to the grieving family. By encouraging families to disucss their wishes and raising the profile of organ donation, awareness can help with this problem.

    I think it’s great you are encouraging an opt out system but please don’t criticise people raising awareness because it still plays a vital part in encouraging people to sign up and even with an opt out awareness would be needed to show people why it is important not to opt out.

  4. Also would just like to point out what you refer to as “eye donation” is generally donation of the corneas to people whose eyes don’t work properly rather than people without eyes receiving a whole eye…

  5. Hello Abi,

    You are right. Eye donation is donation of corneas.

    Also by no means I am criticizing the people raising awareness. They are the first line of defense against the problem.

    However at some point that policy change must occur. That is in long term interest of the blind people(or any other people who need organs)

    There is no country that has made progress because it had strong army of social workers. But every country that has had effective policies has shined on the world map.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: