Before some days, I received some mails which claimed that a giant skeleton was found in India resembling to the description of the character of Ghadotkach in Mahabharata.
Following photos were attached.
..
…..
If you have received this mail, this is Hoax.
Following is more explanation.
- A new skeleton indeed was found in India before a couple of years, but that was skeleton of a dinosaur. The link to that finding is here. Some people are creating confusion and spreading false information.
- Before some time, there was discovery of Homo Floresiensis , a smaller than average human species. This added a new chapter to theory of evolution and made a huge news worldwide. The news was reported in papers world-over. Several scientists rushed to the place for more research, several research papers were written, etc. Skeleton like this would be a bigger deviation to theory of evolution than the Homo Floresiensis and would be a far larger news if this were true. The news coverage would not be limited to a small newspaper.
- The images are clearly altered photographs. In the image where the skeleton is lying around with a bulldozer near its head, the head is clearly not in place where it should be. It is modified to fit in that square pit in picture. Also the surrounding green area in second picture is absent in first picture.
- In the second picture, the head looks at different place than the first one.
- In third picture, the guy sitting there is not somebody you can find digging in a village in remote Northeast. He looks Caucasian with a cowboy hat. Also the skeleton in this picture is lying with legs folded on a VERTICAL wall, very different from that in the first two pictures where the skeleton is lying on ground with legs streatched .
Here is another rational viewpoint. http://www.rationalistinternational.net/article/20041001_en.html
——-
Now see the skeleton vanishing before your own eyes.
Skeleton is ..
…going 
…going.
..gone
About half an hour on paintshop pro. Then some playing around in Irfanview for 5 mins.
I think I don’t even need Paintshop pro. I can do this in Gimp and Irfanview, both free softwares.
Different levels of sharpness or blur in different parts of image is obvious sign that the image is fake. Also abrupt color changes, mismatching shadow directions and micro level details like hand grips, immediately give away faked image.
For all those who still believe there was such a skeleton found , here is the final chapter in the story of Skeleton.
Not all of us take forwarded email as final word of God. One of such rational enthusiasts is Harikumar P. He contacted Archaeological Survey of India and asked them directly about this skeleton. He got letter from Superintendent of ASI , explicitly denying any such finding in India.
Below if the copy of the letter.
Oh, but didn’t the National Geographics Report it too?
Heck no! Here is the copy of email Harikumar forwarded to me.
———- Forwarded message ———-
From: rescor@nationalgeographic.com < rescor@nationalgeographic.com>
Date: 10-Aug-2007 21:08
Subject: Re: Discovery of Gaint Skeleton in India?
Dear Harikumar P:
Thank you for contacting the National Geographic Society.
The story you have seen online is a hoax that’s been floating around over
the Internet for the past few years. Visit the urband legend websites at
http://www.snopes.com/inboxer /hoaxes/giantman.asp
http://urbanlegends.about.com/library/bl_giant_skeleton.htm
for more information and how these photos were put together.
Best wishes,
Lisa T.
National Geographic Society
——————–
(Harikumar, Thanks a ton, for hammering the final nail in the coffin of the giant skeleton.)
Moral of the story- This is FAKE.There are some researchers indeed looking at Mahabharata being a real event in history. But this has nothing to do with it. In fact things like this harm the real researchers.
The issue of ancient Indian civilization is a very large and complex issue. If you are interested, please read my following posts.
My thoughts on Aryan Migration Theory
My thoughts on Aryan Migration Theory - II
—
83 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 16, 2007 at 9:03 pm
Allblogspots
nice blog
May 17, 2007 at 1:31 pm
Erik John Bertel
People love wasting other people’s time. I just hope that Homo floresiensis is not a hoax. I have a vested interest in the Flores Island story, having written a fictional novel on the find. There is more on this ongoing controversy about hobbit Homo floresiensis find at http://www.floresgirl.com.
Erik John Bertel
May 23, 2007 at 1:48 am
bachodi
People do anything to to make Darwin a lier.
May 23, 2007 at 3:38 am
kedarsoman
John,
You are right. I really wonder who begins chain mails like this.
Bachodi,
Very True.
Especially if it is related to hot topic like Mahabharata authenticity.
K
May 24, 2007 at 10:38 am
mahendrap
Thanks! It’s always nice to see someone provide a little “rational enlightenment” on such mystic propaganda…
May 27, 2007 at 9:39 pm
Oliver Jobson
There will always be those idle individuals with time on their hands to create mischief. However, although this article may be a hoax there are accounts of Giants in many of the holy books, heiroglyphs and other ancient documents. There are many things of the past, yet to be discovered, that we know nothing about. You may wish to visit this site: http://www.stevequayle.com/index.html
May 28, 2007 at 5:07 am
Madhu
Also, zoom in on the right hand of the skeleton in second picture. You will see a revolver, like what the cowboys used to have. Modern Ghatotkacha, I presume :-))
May 28, 2007 at 5:19 am
Madhu
Apart from the revolcer I mentioned above, if you keep an open mind (I love these kind of mysteries) and play the devil’s advocate on above comments by the author of this blog:
1. These could be different skeletons, so you see different sites one with grass around and another without near the earthmover. No one said there’s only one skeleton?
2. The last photo with all those guys fitting the archeological frame is not easy to fake. Notice how everything is overlapping and shadows etc.
3. The covering note said this is being investigated by ASI and Nat Geo. So, lots of chances that a caucasian guy is involved.
Well, the revolver still stumps me anyway…..haha.
May 29, 2007 at 3:13 am
kedarsoman
Hello Madhu, thanks for your comments.
The revolver like thing is something vertical protruding out of the ground and its shadow. It is looks like a revolver, but it is not.
About your second comment-
Your point 1- All the mails said “A giant skeleton is found, which is believed to be that of Ghadotkacha”. So safely we can presume that they were talking about only one skeleton.
Your point 2- The photo is morphed well. However one simple thing. See that shadows in left bottom are crisp. The shadows towards top right are rather diffused. That is just one thing.
If you have paintshop pro, then there is a tool called “Clone Pixels”. Try that.
Your point 3 -Could a Caucasian guy come with National Geographic? May be. I give you that. But that still does not explain how the skeleton went from horizontal pit to vertical wall, and from stretched legs to folded legs.
May 31, 2007 at 6:01 am
Oh My God! Where Is The Skeleton Gone? « The Eastern Horizon
[...] Thursday, May 31st, 2007 in giant, mahabharata, hoax, mythology, India, skeleton, history Please refer to my previous post about a skeleton being found in India. [...]
May 31, 2007 at 1:43 pm
kedarsoman
Also check out my next related post at
http://kedarsoman.wordpress.com/2007/05/31/oh-my-god-where-is-the-skeleton-gone/
May 31, 2007 at 9:27 pm
USpace
Good one, too bad it’s a hoax
Wow, I thought it was gonna be a ‘Land of the Giants’ thing for a moment, or evidence of aliens from outer space or of the real Gullliver or something…
absurd thought -
God of the Universe says
don’t try to fool the world
.
June 3, 2007 at 5:01 am
ijmg
Yo sabia que estas fotos eran un fraude. ¿No han notado que en la foto del bulldozer el esqueleto aparentemente tiene una pistola (revolver) en la mano derecha? Sin embargo, si hay descubrimientos verdaderos de gigantes en distintas partes del mundo (no de 10 metros, pero si de mas de 3 metros, con el patron comun de tener 6 dedos en cada mano y pie). Busquen en la net y los hallaran; son de dominio publico.
June 4, 2007 at 3:29 pm
Nikol
my professor showed us this in class today… hmmm i cant believe she didn’t do her research
June 5, 2007 at 6:40 pm
mehulio79
I came across this blog and I thot I’d share it with you regarding this story. The photos are definately fake. Check out the full story: http://around-the-world1.blogspot.com/2007/06/mystery-of-80-feet-tall-human-skeleton.html
June 5, 2007 at 7:52 pm
Pedro
Well… it goes without saying that this picture was treated in in adobe photo shop program just to make the this archeological founding a fake, evidently the first photo is real, but later on appears the same photo already treated in adobe photo treater using the blure tool in the program..listen you dudes..if you are not open maind persons..how are you going to react when all this shit be proven to be true ? what do you think if Darwin evolusionist theory is a fake invented to confuse mankind ?
The 3 photos showed in the top of this page are real, if you do not believe that`s your bussiness…
June 5, 2007 at 10:41 pm
kedarsoman
Hello Mehulio79. Thanks a ton for the link. To all readers, please visit the link by Mehulio. It has the original photos from where the last pic was faked.
—
Hello Pedro. I think all photos are fake. Please see my second post at
http://kedarsoman.wordpress.com/2007/05/31/oh-my-god-where-is-the-skeleton-gone/
About keeping open mind. I will say there is always a tiny tiny chance of this being true and me being wrong. But that chance is less than that of me winning mega lottery jackpot. I would not plan on it , I would not argue in favor of it and I am going to safely assume that this is not true.
June 6, 2007 at 3:20 pm
kedarsoman
In a comment above, Nikol has mentioned this was brought up in her class. I am totally surprised. I just hope it was not anthropology class.
June 9, 2007 at 5:15 pm
Bill
Check the head it`s above the hole level, and shouldn`t it be hundreds of feet underground since it`s over 4000 yrs old…
June 9, 2007 at 5:23 pm
Bill
Check the skull , one has teeth the other doesn`t , one is lookiing towards the front and the other is looking towards your right.
June 9, 2007 at 5:28 pm
Bill
http://www.graphics.cornell.edu/outreach/mastodon/aerial-views.html
June 9, 2007 at 5:34 pm
Bill
un prehistoric elephant
thats where the original pics came from
http://www.graphics.cornell.edu/outreach/mastodon/aerial-views.html
June 11, 2007 at 2:09 pm
Bill
Als0 on the sec9ond picture from top to bottom, the skeleton has a gun jajajajajajja
I just noticed that…….
June 15, 2007 at 1:33 am
Esh
first of all yes the pictures have been treated, yes there has been findings with giant fossils, different species thought you got them ranging from 9 feet all the way to 43 foot. if you do your research there are several accounts through history, http://www.rense.com/general2/giants.htm ohio for example not to go too far. http://www.prospector-utah.com/LAND%20OF%20GIANTS.htm
this page has a lot on the subject
http://s8int.com/giants1.html
and remember that no one creates himself as to think they are God, or to think that they are the only one.
almost all the fossils found belonged to male, so my theory is they could of run out of females for one reason or the other.
also try looking for the fermi paradox, its very interesting and the best part is that its written by top scientists.
another thing is that third picture is real and has nothing to do with the other two, which is a bit obvious but you never know, might get people trying to drown in a glass of water.
blessed be.
June 15, 2007 at 6:14 am
Murph
Hmmmmm I guess Ultra-man never survived that fight with Ghidra. lolz
But anyway… I wish people would stop perpetuating these hoaxes because it takes time away from scientist’s to research this crap when they could be focusing on REAL science, and not trying to find the truth behind these sci-fi claims. I love science fiction, but it needs to stay in books and movies, and OUT of the mainstream science. I know how Thor must have felt about Loki now…
June 16, 2007 at 12:01 am
Top Posts « WordPress.com
[...] Hoax - “Giant Skeleton Found In India” Before some days, I received some mails which claimed that a giant skeleton was found in India resembling to the […] [...]
June 19, 2007 at 5:39 pm
Dana Delgadp
You guys have entirely too much time on your hands.
June 22, 2007 at 1:04 pm
Rui
So do you Dana!!!
June 23, 2007 at 1:22 am
Ahmad Doola
Its nice to see people who are so knowledgable regarding the find, giving their IQ’s away, well done guys! Your reasons proving the pictures are doctered are very scientific, once again, keep up the speculations!!!
June 23, 2007 at 1:02 pm
Nirmal
All I can say is that there is a great mystery behind this. In your point of view these pictures have been faked,I must laud your efforts and your determination of doing researches. But it can also be true. You never know.
June 23, 2007 at 6:06 pm
Victor Pizano
You can even see a gun in the second picture. Where did that come from?
June 25, 2007 at 6:02 pm
Nirmal
Yep, I can see that some of the pictures have been tampered with…!
Don’t know wat they wanted to do!!!
July 1, 2007 at 8:22 pm
Linda
To me this is all real. I read Mahabarat……….its a book from India and their were people who was this big. What people want to say, that books are fake too. How can we think we were the only type of people, just how dinosor was discovered then why not other things as well. What some people wants us to think is that we came from monkey and nothing more. Scientis did not created this word. They could be so many other things out there that we don’t even know about. I do believe that we need to open our minds to other things and not be limited to what scientis say to us. If this is real or not real i do believe that othere humans were here before us. I didnt come from no damn monkey!
July 24, 2007 at 4:42 am
Booven
Well, I had to agree vt Linda. I belive its true. Though the comments made here does makes sense but for me, I think there are some kind of speculations involved, to make non belivers support their theory. I choose to belive this.
July 24, 2007 at 4:55 am
kedarsoman
Linda,
Personally I think Mahabharat is a story based on facts. As far as human element in Mahabharat is considered, people and their emotions, I think that might be true. As far as all the mystical stuff is considered, well, we have no proof.
Lot of people argue that “well, they mentioned airplanes, so they must be having airplanes.” My answer is “Harry Potter uses flying brooms, but that does not mean flying brooms are available in U.K.” Artist’s imagination always runs a few steps ahead of reality.
We need to keep our minds open, yes. But we must keep them open for objective facts, not for beliefs and superstitions.
Booven,
I wish I could agree with you. I am a stunch believer that Mahabharata happened, but not the mustical part.
Could there be a skeleton of giant Ghatotkacha lying somewhere? May be yes with a minute possibility.
Is this a skeleton of a giant which resembles Ghatotkacha? Hell No. This one is fake.
July 25, 2007 at 1:20 am
Juan Pérez
Chingen a su madre, mejor les vendemos las piramides de Chichen Itza…bara bara y de remate !!!
July 27, 2007 at 10:16 pm
Nicolas Pereyra Molinas
I have receive these photos with the commentaries in spanish. Searching in the National Geographic web site, I did not find anything and it was strange. Luckily quickly I arrived here to clarify all this.
Thank you,
Nicolás Pereyra
July 30, 2007 at 9:48 am
chetan pai
i cant imagine to see such a big skeleton of Bhima’s son Ghatotkacha.Giant Skeleton Found In India” Before some days, I received some mails which claimed that a giant skeleton was found in India resembling to the […] […]
August 8, 2007 at 11:58 am
Harikumar P
yes, This news is a Hoax.
Even a Kannada News paper has published the same story.
A short translated summary of the news report is as follows: The Indian Team of National Geographic in association with Indian Army have found a Large Human Skeleton in the army controlled region of Kurukshetra. The Skeleton is said to be about 50 feet in height. The width of its head itself is said to be about 3 feets. Many inscriptions’ and shashanaas have also been discovered from the spot.
Immediately, I have filed an application under Right to Information Act 2005 for obtaining all the details including photos and documents related to such discovery directly to the Hon’ble Prime Minister’s Office as always I do.
The application is then transferred to Archeological Survey of India, Chandigarh Region through its Head Office based at New Delhi.
But shockingly I have received a reply from the Superintending Archeologist of Archeological Survey of India stating that NO Such discovery has been reported anywhere in that region.
The copy of the reply can be provided.
So sad. This type of Hoax is creating a great confusion and it indeed creating a false representation to the society that all the claims of Hindus are false.
It does not mean that everything in Hindu Mythology is false. We are yet to discover a strong proof , that’s all.
August 11, 2007 at 5:23 am
silvereene
You stupid morons. Open your eyes finally and see the truth. For hundreds of years there were phenomenons that were considered not to be possible and real and now they are… Remember the electricity? Magnetism… All about the space and the universe…
I believe old legends say just the facts, true facts… And we rather live in our cube of well-known things, satisfied and we don’t allow new facts to come… That’s all our problem of “not-believing”. Try to read some historical books! Wish you were crying when the truth is out… Stupid people! Stupid satisfied people…
August 28, 2007 at 5:15 am
kedarsoman
These were comments on my post “Oh My God!! Where Is The Skeleton Gone.” Since I merged the skeleton related posts into one, I am merging the comments as well.
—
3 comments
———-
May 31st, 2007 at 9:17 pm
USpace
Wow, I thought it was gonna be a “Land of the Giants’ thing for a moment.
Just as well, given all the other fossils and old skeletons we have found, and that this was a human skeleton in a shallow grave, to think we would have never found this earlier had it been true, is depressing in itself.
.
absurd thought -
God of the Universe says
don’t play hoaxes on people
.
——————
June 5th, 2007 at 6:52 am
bachodi
Always thought so. But never went deep inside.
August 28, 2007 at 5:18 am
kedarsoman
These are comments on my post “Final Nail In The Coffin Of Giant Skeleton.” I merged the post. So I am merging the comments as well.
—-
4 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 22nd, 2007 at 12:45 am
ankabyuth
(edit)
Would this be the same skeleton of a giant human?
http://onetrueblog.wordpress.com/2007/08/09/giants-walked-amongst-us/
August 22nd, 2007 at 6:04 am
kedarsoman
(edit)
Hey Ankabyuth,
Yes, exactly the same skeleton.
K
August 23rd, 2007 at 11:42 am
ankabyuth
(edit)
Amazing how the same two photos gave rise to 2 different hoax stories.
thanks for bringing this version to my attention. keep on debunking those myths.
August 27th, 2007 at 5:25 pm
bachodi
(edit)
August 30, 2007 at 1:16 am
srinu
public ko chutia mat bana-e-a
September 8, 2007 at 11:19 pm
Hahaha FAKE!
Pedro please, look at the color picture whit grass in it. Estimated by the “man” standing up they would have dug down atleast halv a meter (2feet) around the excavation site, (the grass is at a higher elevation). Look at pictures of other excavation sites, they dont dig around like that! And why the hell would they waste time, money and energy on a stupid thing like that?! And its a fake, ok. Its a picture of a homicide scene. Ive seen this picture before, on the Discorery Channel. Its the remains of a teenager that was murderd by his father and he buried his son in the backyard.
September 9, 2007 at 11:25 am
Naveen
I was searching on more news related to the gair.. after it was reported by a daily newspaper on its front page in Indore….Madhya Pradesh….I was more happpy when I saw this blog….I havce passed it on to an edtor of an another newspaper….
by the way how do u make a blog…can u teach me ?
October 5, 2007 at 11:32 am
roly
The photops are real; if you read Tueaday Lobsang Rampa’s the Opening of the third eye you will come across reference to exactly these kind of skeletons. In addition before Homo floresiensis no-one would have believed that a human being could be fully formed at such a small size. It is likely that ‘giant man’ is a product of unusual environmental factors. Fianlly most cultures contain myths of giant people and these people are depicted throughout history - take the cerne abbas man in Southern England for example.
October 5, 2007 at 1:44 pm
jose
Definately this is real. I am from Spain and when I was a child my grandfather took me into the mountains and showed me a large skeleton in a sacred place just like these - please contact me if you want the photos he kept of this
October 11, 2007 at 3:18 am
Gerardo Hoogesteyn
The email I received had a fifth picture attached, of a skeleton in a square grave, the one you mention above with the bulldozer. If you look closely you´ll see its the same one in the grave above
October 23, 2007 at 10:39 pm
Adam
Well there is a problem with this article when comparing pictures. The first pic, of course, is not going to show the green grassy area because it is a CLOSE-UP of the skeleton so therefore, you CAN NOT compare it to the first pic by that. Second, those are not in the same area. The first pic and the second are not of the same origin. They ARE from 2 different places. Last, the 3rd picture of the skeleton with it knees bent does not mean that could not be real just because the first skeleton was “found” with it’s leg straight. People die in all sorts of ways and angles. You CAN NOT say just because you found a skeleton of a regular human lying straight down, that the next one you find…let’s say…praying on it’s knees covered from volcanic ash or something…that it’s automatically fake. That’s ridiculous. You never know though….they could be real. THE GOVERNMENT IS EXTREMELY GOOD AT COVERING THINGS UP. Do you honestly believe that we are the only inteligent beings in this WHOLE universe???
October 29, 2007 at 10:28 pm
Robert
I do think there were giants at one time on the earth. Please send the copies to me so I will have more evidence of this. Thank you. Robert L.
October 29, 2007 at 10:30 pm
Robert
wow!
October 29, 2007 at 10:49 pm
Robert
Jose, if what you say is true, take your photos to a digital photo shop, have them copied, send them out on youtube along with where these locations of the giant(s) can be found. Thank you, Robert L.
October 29, 2007 at 10:55 pm
Robert
Check this link out. [http://www.graphics.cornell.edu/outreach/mastodon/aerial-views.html]
October 29, 2007 at 11:03 pm
Robert
http://www.worth1000.com/cache/gallery/contestcache…. Another Link to check out.
October 31, 2007 at 10:17 am
Ryan
This is absolutely absurd. Apparently(with a little research), this was initially
a photoshop composition contest and people starting giving and spreading
misinformation to the masses. I found it intrigueing…. however, silly.
November 1, 2007 at 5:06 pm
sougata sarkar
nice April fool’s material.
but i must appreciate the hard work involved in making the thing seem real.
for a second even the abnormally irrespondable person on earth may jump up on his toes.
November 9, 2007 at 2:30 am
Jim
Something I would like to add is that it seems to be impossible for the human form to come in such sizes anyway.
This is not my own theory, I have read it in a physics book more than 15 years ago.
If there was a human body that was scaled up 5 times from normal, it’s weight would be multiplied by 5×5x5=125, because weight is related to volume and all three dimensions would be multiplied by 5… etc.
On the other hand, bone strength is related to it’s cross-section which would be only multiplied by 5×5=25.
So, a bigger human would have to have much thicker (proportionally) bones to carry it’s weight. It wouldn’t just be scaled up.
Please correct me if I am wrong and excuse me if someone else has already posted something like this. I didn’t take the time to read everything in detail.
November 11, 2007 at 6:08 am
Jim Tafoya
When and if a gigantic human skeleton is discovered, there will be tremendous publicity surounding the event. Anything else should be considered as some lame brained waste of lifes energy perpertrated by someone who won’t even claim credit for it publicly. Anyone who believes such nonsense is even more pathetic. not to say that gigantic people never existed, I believe they did, but , considering all the money and fame that would come to the dicoverer, and human nature being what it is, there would be no secret about the discovery, it would be front page news all over the world. For weeks!
November 24, 2007 at 2:28 pm
zorawar
Dear all,whatever people say or do to create misguidance,it will allways be in “both ways”,wich means that its not “convenient” to expose some facts of not so recent discoveries on the ground of gigantic skelletons of humanoids,they were found in many countries,pictures were taken,films were made etc etc and all disapears in flows of smoke…WHY? well.before we say what possible reasons could be,think…do we get the correct facts on any important event? no matter what goes on,a lot of powerfull groups that call themselves the elected ones (on any subject ) have demonstrated trough out times,that the power of information is higher than any other social power…so before saying such things are “hoax” or not investigate also the “investigators”..for there is a source of great unmeasurable deviation of painful to ego truth….
December 15, 2007 at 8:25 am
Nephilim70
Quite right Zorawar,
Disinformation seems to get more airtime than real scientific discovery. We are living in an age of Disinformation and deception on our Television news broadcasts. With “breaking News” these days being Distraction101. A few “Giant” hoaxers muddy the waters for the real discoveries that are being well concealed. This is the modus Operandi of the slave controllers.
@ Jim Tafoya? Those kinds of stories just do not make it to the headlines anymore. If they ever did there would be 10 very well paid “Scientific experts” ready to debunk ANYTHING that questions the neat boundaries of our “accepted sciences” we are taught.
“In an age of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.”
-George Orwell-
December 25, 2007 at 8:00 am
AntiNWO
The explanation given by Lisa T from the National Geographic Society is pathetic, as are her photos using paintshop pro.
Photo 1 & 4: Lisa T states as proof that the image is a fake that the head is not where it should be, so as to fit in the square pit, crap. Look at the other bones and see the decay and then consider also movement over time. Regarding the square pit, these pictures don’t have the edge of the pit showing past the head of this skeleton. Bulldozer, what bulldozer all I see is formwork to sure up the walls of the dig.
“Also the surrounding green area in second picture is absent in first picture.” You people buy this crap without looking at what crap Lisa T is trying to shovel. Firstly the 1st and 4th (Same) images are croped so as to not have any hope of having any green area. Second, I’m not convinced that these are the same skeletons I.e the 2nd image seems to have a darkened area on the left hand side of the skull.
Photo 2: Lisa T states that “the head looks at different place than the first one”. First I cant’ see this nor do I buy this. Second could this be due to the first picture having a greater depth of excavation and things possibly having shifted. Third, as stated I’m not convinced that it’s the same skeleton, nor do I care that this second image is real. I say this in that the 1st, 3rd and 4th images are authentic in my opinion.
Photo 3: Is this the kind of personel that the national geographic society (small caps) hires? So what if this guy in the photo is not a local? What kind of argument is this as to the photo being a fake? Second, the reason that the photo is in a wall and vertical and “very different” is because it’s a different photograph, different skeleton. Lisa T you are a M.ron.
The fact that the Indian Government, the national geographic society and Harikumar P tries to say these photos are a hoax means nothing. Governments etc have and continue to deny the real truth and keep people in the dark.
Darwin and Eugenics are from the same pit as are the arguments they propose. For those that don’t have a vested interest in continuing to shovel the lies the establishment pushes, use the internet to discover the real truth.
December 27, 2007 at 8:20 pm
Hindutva’s ‘Giant Mahabharatha skeleton Found’ story is a hoax « Super Hindus around the globe
[...] More at http://kedarsoman.wordpress.com/2007/05/16/hoax-giant-skeleton-found-in-india/ [...]
January 14, 2008 at 8:22 pm
slav
I bet you the skeleton indeed is real. National geographic will do everything in their power to stop such things to become public. Yet this did and of course, lets call it a hoax and say its photoshopped!
January 23, 2008 at 7:31 pm
Chriss
You are on of this people that say
Ohh we are the only life in this universe oh yea and this planet belongs too us
I need one look on a night sky with stars and i now that there is something
bigger then us
1 more
People when your GOD is so great and full of love and and why he don’t came only one time down only one
AND STOP THE MONEY WE DON’T NEED IT WE ONLY NEED AIR
February 2, 2008 at 5:16 pm
gnyanesh chokshi
THOSE WHO ARE WEAK AND WITHOUT COURAGE OR CONVICTION TRY TO GAIN REFLECTED GLORY BY ATTEMPTING TO GLORIFY AND MYSTIFY PAST AND/OR PRESENT OF THE COUNTRY OR ITS LEGENDS , CAUSE SENSATION AND FEEL GREAT WITHIN THEMSELVES. THERE ARE GULLIBLES IN THE WORLD IN GENERAL AND INDIA IN PARTICULAR WHO ACCEPT SUCH HOAX AND IF ANY ONE QUESTIONS HE IS ANTY NATIONAL ANTY HINDUTVA. ITS THE PITY THAT SUCH PEOPLE RETARD THE SOCIAL RESTRUCTURING AND MOVEMENT TOWARDS THE GLORIOS FUTURE FOR THE INDIAN SOCIETY.
February 7, 2008 at 1:53 pm
Claudio
The comment posted by Jim (november the 09th, 2007), said all. The bones, mainly in the legs, must be thicker to manage the weight of a giant in the earth’s gravitational field. So, all pictures are falsified.
February 22, 2008 at 12:43 pm
j4vi5
when you guy’s figure out whats going on it will be to late.no one can make you believe anything. but they can try to make you not believe.serch for yourself. come to your own conclusion people. wake up……we were born in this world. many things are hidden from us. if it is logical and you believe we had giant lizard reptails ( dinasours) why do you not believe in giant human beings.don’t believe every thing somone tell you. search and come to your own conclusion.a noob could do the photoshop foolishness the guy did on this page.
February 22, 2008 at 12:48 pm
j4vi5
one more thing if this is a hoax . can some one tell me were the giant frame came from or who built it, i’ll wait. the dam thing is real.but to admit that wud prove that alot of other things are real as well. do the maths
March 2, 2008 at 8:29 am
Chris
I have heard many stories of “giants” of old walking the earth, and skeletons being undcovered in the early 1900’s. Every culture on the planet has similar stories, including American Indians. If you go to a European country, you will see that the doors for alot of buildings are very tall, and they too have a history of giant stories. Coincidents? Nah. I think the powers that be have tried very hard to hide all of the evidence all over the world that these giants existed, are being discovered all over the world. It’s part of an agenda to dicredit the Bible, which discusses giants more than once. I think they used paintshop pro to take the skeleton out of the photos, and say it’s a hoax. Noone would spend years of their lives and days to create a hoax out of alot of research. Ask the Russian scientists and researches who go all over the world to find these things if they are real. You think the Russians are interested in wasting time and money on creating a hoax to disprove the Bible by digging these up and taking photos? Hell no! When someone finds one, people come and take it away. If any of you find one, someone will come and take it from you. National Geographic undoubtedly know for a fact that these skeletons are real, and they for sure have seen them and taken photos of them. They also have a bullshit polotical and anti-religion agenda. Ask Islamic leaders if these things existed. They believe in the same historical past as the Christians do, according to the Bible. Go ahead and tell them that they are wrong about this topic, and they are liars, too, creating a hoax. See what happens. Ask the Isreali’s if they have any doubt that King David fought a giant, or if they have found skeletons in Isreal. See what happens. If these are all hoax’s, then why are there so many cases all over the world, finding the same giants? In places where the tribes are not interested in hoax’s or agenda’s?
1
March 6, 2008 at 9:06 am
Kenneth
Another thing that proves that this is a hoax, is what you don’t see. If this was such a huge discovery, then why are there only two people seen in the photo? There should be a swarm of people taking measurements and photos. Also scientist know that earths oxygen levels determine how big living things can grow and live on the planet. The oxygen was to thin 4000 years ago to allow such large creatures to grow or live on this planet. Another thing that say HOAX, is the condition of the skeleton. The skeleton would have almost completely decayed being so close to the surface. Its just funny to listen to the believers, they are so gullible!
March 11, 2008 at 2:15 am
Harsh Patel
This skeleton if of aurjuns son in the anchint indian book of Mahabarata the death of a huge giant was recorded in the book one million years ago and they found it in the same place it said it was dead what do u call that a kwidence? ya right.
April 16, 2008 at 1:40 pm
elzouine
The hole should have been a lot deeper if it was dug for a dead giant by ohter giants. This one lays very close to the surface. I don’t believit al all. by the way: it would have been world news, in every news media, if it was thrue.
April 18, 2008 at 1:56 am
Paul Villacorta
I dont know I have to believe this or not… But I’ve read about the Nibiru thing.. this might be related with the Giant Skeletons found..
April 24, 2008 at 10:24 pm
Natalie
The photo where you have made the giant skeleton dissappear to validate it was a hoax was reprinted in World Explorer Vol. 4 No. 9. Where David Hatcher Childress is the founder. The caption below that photo reads:
excavations at the mound uncovered at the Star Man Complex in central Michigan. First mentioned in the “Thunder Bay Clarion” in a front page article in 1976, this giant skeleton was excavated by amateure archeologists and then quickly buried again when local historical society threatened legal action. The “Clarion” changed its name over the years to the “Thunder Bay Ledger, which featured this photo in its Sunday supplement, Whacton Weekend”, for November 4, 1984.
You can all start your research on that photo with the above information. These giants support the bible. These giants are just another stumbling block for Darwinists just like all those supposed links to man are being revealed of no genetic relation to man. The more you use modern science to try to prove Darwinism as the ultimate truth, the more you realize that Darwin was wrong. I’m so sorry your scientific results have proven you wrong. Keep trying to prove that man is a worthless creature so you don’t feel bad about all the ones being butchered or starving in Africa. You all know deep down in your itty bitty god/(Jesus Christ) hating hearts that Darwin was wrong. They cover up the truth about the Giants because it confirms what the bible says about Giants.
May 8, 2008 at 4:24 pm
Zie L.
Until we get the scientific orthodox people to stop working in conjuction with the super elite that tried everything within their power to suppress the truth(because they want a world without anything else but their manipulated disinformation to control your mind and your total unconscious submission…hahaha), you won’t see anything that will contradict the dogmatic Darwinistic theory militarily enforced in every level of our school teaching. I don’t care if this is a hoax or not, the real scientist with bone will actually go out to the actual site and dig for himself to prove either way, otherwise people are just blobbing their mouths with psudo science point of view.
May 14, 2008 at 8:42 pm
Hedonico
So much for these giants…I have read numerous reports of such findings but not a single one shows any photos. Too bad. I do believe they may have existed, though.
However, all you “experts” (joking) missed a very, VERY SIMPLE observation: The photo with the bulldozer projects a shadow; if you look at the angle of the shadow, the cranium of the skeleton should also project a shadow in the same direction and it would be definitely visible. It is not!!!
Cheers,
hedonico.
May 15, 2008 at 7:12 am
ullas
is it true?
June 2, 2008 at 3:34 am
sandeep
its not true
June 5, 2008 at 1:08 am
koolaid
the only giant is yao ming from huston…hahaha
June 9, 2008 at 7:00 pm
hedonico
Well, the other “giant” that I know of is a Japanese athlete from the ’70’s. He was about 7 feet tall and was under treatment to stop growing!!! No joke!
There are actually reports of giant Native Americans in the 1800’s and there is actually a photo of one of them somewhere. I saw that in the internet and I believe that is a real shot. Apparently the early “pioneers” (a very, VERY gentle term for those who massacred the Native Americans) did find many giant skeletons in the East Coast and other areas and it seems to be documented; of course, this happened before the photographic camera was in vented so there are no photos of that time but there are definitely documented reports of that and if you search the internet you’ll find them.
As for the one in India, again, I do not think it is impossible that large humans may have existed there; however, the photo we’ve all been discussing is a genuine hoax. Again, the shadows reveal a lot and there is no more need to analyze the photo with that simple detail.
Cheers,
Hedonico
June 16, 2008 at 11:55 am
sachin
Long long time ago Human were very tall and healthy.And when they start alchohal, smoking and other things they becomes short. And after some time people will become more shorter then current people.If we do not leave smoking and drinking our next genratin will become more shorter than us.
June 21, 2008 at 3:33 pm
Ophelan
It may be that the true hoax is by the person trying to prove the pictures a hoax. It would be just as easy to take real pictures and remove the skeleton as it would be to place a skeleton in the picture. Its all so funny how we have our agendas and flock to birds with common feathers.
When something is presented like these pictures skepticism is best at first, then real investigation should follow. One that includes experts and not guesses by those who have an agenda to debunk. A hoax can be proven to be a hoax along the way and a cover up can be revealed. But what if the reported pictures are proven real by the investigation? Don’t you think that we all should follow what is real, instead of those things we believe that would be proven to be false by the reality that this picture and other pictures that are in question on other subjects have been proven to be authentic?
Honesty Gentlemen, honesty is still the best policy. Withhold your judgments until a real investigation takes place. Otherwise all you have is an opinion and they are like our assholes. We all have one.
June 28, 2008 at 2:44 am
hedonico
Dear Ophelan:
I could not agree more with you. Judgments, especially unfounded, are most harmful. Sure, honesty is needed as well as true, objective investigation.
One thing, however; few, VERY FEW people can make a distinction between OPINION and FACTUAL OBSERVATION; most people have and express opinions, and most opinions are driven by belief, not by factual knowledge.
As for my personal point, my point stands: The projected shadow of the bulldozer and the missing shadow of the cranium is a clear observation, not an opinion.
Cheers to all.
Hedonico.